Please enable JavaScript.

Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.

God (Argument from Evil (Is Theism Inconsistent with Evil? (a & d are…

- - - - Weirob: Athiest,
        
        Cohen: Neutral
  - - - World must be perfect
    - - Parody
        
        Guy goes around with these beliefs
        and sees people dying for no reason
  - - - one has to be eliminated
      - Theodicy
        
        Attempts to answer why a good God permits evil
  - - - Do we really have free will if we can't do evil
      - The goodness of evil outweighs the suffering
    - - Tokyo firebombing wow
      - Natural evil vs Agent Caused
        
        Earthquakes
        
        The devil did it
        
        devil has free will
- - - - Elicit (draw out) a confession
      - 1) Pious is what E is doing now
        
        Only naming one thing, not general principle
      - 2) Pious is what the gods like
        
        Gods are always angry, disagree on what piety is
      - 3) Pious is what all gods love
    - - 4) Does god define piety, or is piety loved by god
        
        Euthyphro question !
        
        Peep direction
        
        do the gods make piety
        
        does piety influence the gods
        
        Euthyphro: Man idk
        
        Socrates: Piety might relate to justice (how people deal with each other)
        
        True piety is a part of justice
        
        Shame is a part of fear
    - - 5) Piety is caring for the gods with prayer and sacrifice
        
        Euthyphro has special knowledge on god
        
        Objection: but the gods dont gain anything
        
        but it makes the gods happy
      - 6) The pious is what all the gods love
  - - - "not as smart as you think"
    - - Charity
        
        Soc Irony allowed Euth to draw out his best argument
- - - - Purpose
        
        Object does something that intelligent person sees as valuable
      - Intolerance
        
        Purpose cannot be done if a part is taking out
        
        Intolerant to change
      - Other Shit
        
        Doesnt matter if
        
        origins aren't seen
        
        if theres some malfunctions
        
        Self replication hella impressive
    - - P1: Watch is different from a rock because it has purpose
        
        P2: Watch has a creator that gave it purpose
        
        P3: The eye has purpose
        
        Conclusion: Eye has a creator that gave it purpose
  - - - Prove that things that can qualify as design are created from small steps in evolution
        
        P1 is false
    - - Can peep the story of how the eye came to be through evolution
      - Every small step gives it survival value
        
        P2 gone
    - - METHINKS IT IS LIKE A WEASEL
        
        random 28 letter word has to lead to this
        
        keep on hitting random, but the right letters keep
      - Vs just hitting random everytime