Migration
Field Note: Risking Lives for Remittances
What is Migration?
Immigrants risk their lives to get to Europe, North America, Australia, and China for better opportunities.
The United States uses a "wet foot, dry foot" policy with Cuban immigrants; if they are intercepted at sea, they are deported, but if they make it to land, they can stay.
Perception is an overwhelming factor in migration: as long as immigrants perceive a better life abroad, they will continue to migrate.
Remittances are the money that migrants send back to their home/families. Remittances is Haiti make up over 30% of their gross domestic product, more than exports. When the US's economy dropped, migrants started asking for money from their home country; these are called reverse remittances.
Out of the 31.2 million immigrants in the US, 20.4 million are legal. The Dominican Republic is the US's 2nd largest source of immigrants, after Mexico. The majority of agricultural worker also comes from Mexico
After 9/11, the US built fences along its Mexican border, hired more border patrols, and installed new technology to intercept terrorists. The walls are designed so that people can't climb over them, but so people can speak with each other. They are marked with memorials and empty water bottles for Mexicans who died crossing the border.
NAFTA- North American Free Trade Agreement: between US, Canada, and Mexico
Cyclic Movement
Begins at our home base and brings us back to it. Most people have a daily routine that has short moves in a local area called activity spaces.
Cyclic Movement involves shorter periods away from home; Periodic Movement involves longer periods away from home; Migration involves a degree of permanence.
Commuting is a cyclic movement. Another form is seasonal movement; this has huge economic consequences.
Another type of cyclic movement is nomadism, which is a matter of survival, culture, and tradition. Nomadic movement is purposeful and takes place along familiar routes repeated time and time again.
Periodic Movement
A type of periodic movement is migrant labor. The need migrant labor is the farm fields of the US creates a large flow of cross-border movers, many who become immigrants.
A specialized system of periodic movement is transhumance, which is a system of pastoral farming where ranchers move livestock according to seasonal availability of pastures. Unlike nomadism, this involves a long period of residential relocation. It can be found in Switzerland and the "Horn of Northeast Africa.
Military Service is another kind of periodic movement. In a year, 10 million people and their families are moved to new locations. Going to a far away college is also a periodic movement.
Migration
International migration is movement across country borders; also called transnational migration. Internal Migration occurs within a single countries borders. Ex: African Americans migrating from south to north for jobs during the early 20th century.
Mobility in the US depends on the economy. In 2007 and 2008, the mobility was the lowest since the war because of the downturn of the economy. The mortgage crisis and higher unemployment rates led to a reduction in long-distance moves.
After reaching their destination country, many international immigrants also migrate internally. Many people migrated to the south in the 1990's because of the warm climates and available jobs.
In Peru, the pattern of mobility is from rural to urban. The capital, Lima, is the global and national investment capital and is the major focus of economic opportunity for the rural population. Lima receives the majority of Peru's migrants.
Why Do People Migrate?
Forced migration involves the imposition of authority or power, producing involuntary migration. Voluntary migration occurs after a migrant weighs options and choices, and can be analyzed/understood as a series of options/choices.
The migration of the Irish can be seen as forced because of the British treatment of them and the potato famine. It can also been seen as voluntary in that the Irish chose to go to North America.
Studies show that men migrate more and farther than women; men generally have better job opportunities and get paid better. Mexican households with a strong patriarchal system shield young women from migration and send young men out to work. If they don't have a strong system, young unmarried women get sent to the city/another country to gain employment.
The decision to migrate happens to an individual migrant within a household, place, country, region, or world, each of which has it's own dynamics.
Forced Migration
The largest and most devastating forced migration was the Atlantic slave trade. Between 12-30 million slaves were brought from Africa to South America, the Caribbean, and North America.
A majority of the Africans were forced into the Caribbean region; from coastal Central America to Brazil.
Wealth promised through plantation agriculture from the southeastern US to Brazil created a demand for slaves by plantation owners.
Sugar was the most economically important crop in the 1700s followed by coffee, cotton and fruit.
Most impacted region tbd
African civilization took a major hit after the slave trade. Many people in the Caribbean are of African-Caribbean descent, and there are not many indigenous people left on the islands.
Although no other forced migration compares to the Atlantic slave trade, others have changed the worlds demographic map.
In 1788, Great Britain shipped shipped tens of thousands of convicts to Australia.
In the 1800s, the US government took land from the Native Americans and forcibly moved the tribes.
Between the late 1920s and 1953, Stalin's government moved millions of non-Russians from their homes to remote parts of Siberia and Asia for political reasons.
During the 1930s, Nazis forced Jews from portions of western Europe.
The first spike in the US Coast Guards interdiction of Haiti immigrants came in 1991, after democratically elected President Aristide was overthrown with military rule. The second spike came in1994, after came as Aristide was being reinstated as President under US pressure.
After the 2012 earthquake, the Department of Homeland Security granted all Haiti nationals an 18 month temporary protected status.
Many Afghans have fled to Pakistan and Iran to seek safety from the civil war, then the Taliban, and currently the instability of Afghan War.
After the Taliban took control of Afghanistan, the Pakistan government forced the repatriation of thousands of Afghans; they sent the refugees back to Afghanistan.
Push and Pull Factors in Voluntary Migration
Ravenstein's Laws of Migration
- Every migration flow generates a return or counter-migration
- The majority of migrants move a short distance
- Migrants who move longer distances tend to choose big-city destinations
- Urban residents are less migratory than inhabitants of rural areas
- Families are less likely to make international moves than young adults
The gravity model predicts interaction between places on the basis of their population size and distance between them.
(Population*Population) / distance between populations
Push Factors are the conditions and perceptions that help the migrant decide to leave a place. Pull Factors are the circumstances that effectively attract the migrant to certain locales from other places, the decision on where to go.
Because a migrant is more familiar with his/her place of residence than the locale he/she is moving, the migrant will perceive push factors more accurately than pull factors.
Distance decay affects pull factors. The farther away a destination is, the less information a migrant has on that place, which makes it less likely that they will migrate there.
Step migration is the idea that migration consists of a series of stages instead of a long unbroken route. Intervening opportunity is when a migrant stops at one of the steps along the way to get to their destination, and stays there instead.
Types of Push and Pull Factors
Legal Status
Migrants can arrive legally in a country and get a visa. They can also arrive illegally and risk being deported.
Economic Conditions
Poverty drives migrants from their homelands to places with perceived opportunities. Lower economic positions of migrants in their host countries can lead to exploitation.
The United Nations Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Their Families establishes a standard of treatment for migrant workers. The US has not signed it along with 16 of the G-20 states.
The European Union is a political and economic union of 28 states. The G-20 are the 20 largest economies in the world.
Power Relationships
Gender, ethnicity, race, and money are all factors in the decision to migrate. Employers of migrant workers often have perceptions of what kind of migrants would work best for them.
A study in Toronto showed that nanny agencies portrayed certain ethnicity according to stereotypes and contractors are known to hire Mexicans based on their racial stereotype.
Political Circumstances
Throughout history oppressive regimes have engendered migration streams.
Desperate migrants fled Vietnam by the hundreds of thousands after communists took control in 1975.
in 1972 Uganda's dictator Idi Amin, expelled 50,000 Asians and Ugandans of Asian descent from his country.
The Cuban communist dictatorship expelled more than 125,000 Cubans in 1980 int the "Mariel Boatlift."
Politically driven flows are marked by both escape and expulsion.
Armed Conflict and Civil War
A conflict in the former Yugoslavia during the 1900s drive 3 million people from their home, mostly into Western Europe
During the mid-1900s, a civil war engulfed Rwanda and pitted militant Hutu against the minority Tutsi and "moderate" Hutu. It killed 800,000-1 million and produced a huge migration flow into Congo and Tanzania. More than 2 million fled Rwanda.
Environmental Conditions
Environmental crisis's such as earthquakes, hurricanes, and volcanic eruptions can stimulate migration.
The population of New Orleans dropped 11% as a result of hurricane Katrina. The proportion of children also fell from 27% to 23%; families with children are moving out of the city center and into the suburbs.
After the volcanic eruption on Montserrat, there was a migration flow because of the still active volcano. Half of the island is now an Exclusion Zone and people aren't allowed in this zone. The remaining people have to live in the north where the soil is thin and the land is rocky, making it difficult to live. Over 7000 people migrated off of the island, leaving 3000 to go to the north.
Culture and Traditions
When the British partitioned South Asia into a mainly Hindu India and almost exclusively Muslim Pakistan, millions of Muslims from India migrated to Pakistan and vice versa with the Hindus from Pakistan.
In the 1990s, more than 2 millions Jews left the former Soviet Union for Israel and other destinations.
The decline in white power and uncertain political conditions in South Africa during the mid 1990s impelled many whites to emigrate to Australia, Europe, and North America.
Technological Advances
Although most refugees still move by foot, some use modern forms of transportation and communication, which can encourage immigration.
News travels faster now, including job opportunities and ways to reach their destination.
A Kinship Link is a migrant that is pulled more towards a destination where family and friends have already succeeded.
Geographers call flows along and through kinship links chain migration. When a migrant reassures family and friends that a new community has been formed, this encourages further migration along that chain.
Chains of migration built upon each other create immigration waves or swells in migration from one origin to the same destination.
Where Do People Migrate?
Global Migration Flows
Colonization is a physical process whereby the colonizer takes over another place, putting its own government in charge and either moving its own people into the place or bringing in indentured outsiders to gain control of the people and the land.
Before 1500, long-distance,global-scale migration occurred haphazardly, typically in pursuit of spices, fame, or exploration.
The Europeans first colonized the Americas, the coasts of Africa, and parts of Asia from the 1500s to the 1800s. Then, Europeans colonized interior Africa and Asia starting in the late 1800s and into the 1900s.
Europeans emigrated the the Americas slowly. Before 1830s, 2.75 million Europeans left to settle overseas. The British went to North America, Australia, New Zealand, and South Africa.
From Spain and Portugal, hundreds of thousands of Europeans emigrated to Middle and South America. The rate of European emigration increased sharply between 1835 and 1935, with 75 million departing for colonies in Africa and Asia, and for economic opportunities in the Americas.
African slaves were the first non-American Indian settlers in the Americas. As this was happening, the British took control of South Asia and transported tens of thousands of "indentured" worker from present day India, Pakistan, and Sri Lanka to East and South Africa. The British also relocated Asians from India to Caribbean countries.
Regional Migration Flows
Economic Opportunities
An Island of Development is when port cities become islands of economic development within larger undeveloped regions
Young men migrated to coastal Nigeria to work in the oil economy and sent home money to their families, until 1980s when the economy took a fall. The Nigerian government forcibly pushed out 2 million foreign workers.
Millions of Chinese workers fled famine and political strife in southern China to work as contract laborers in Southeast Asia. Many remained and their descendants contribute to a Chinese minority in Southeastern Asian countries. The Chinese in Southeast Asia became leader in trade, commerce, and finance.
Reconnection of Cultural Groups
From 1919 to 1948, the UK of Great Britain and Northern Ireland held control over Palestine, and Britain encouraged the Jews to migrate back to it. In 1948, 750,000 Jews lived in Palestine when the UN partitioned the area as the independent state of Israel. After this, 600,000 Palestinian Arabs fled out of Israeli territories to Jordan, Egypt, Syria, and beyond.
Through a series of wars, Israel expanded its area of territorial control and built settlements in Palestinian territories.
Conflict and War
After WW2, 15 million Germans migrated westward. Before the Berlin Wall was built, several million Germans fled Soviet-controlled East Germany into what was then West Germany. Millions of migrants left Europe to go to the US, Canada, Australia, Israel, Argentina, Brazil, and Venezuela. 8 million people in total.
Fidel Castro came to power in Cuba in 1959. During the 1960s, the Cuban government was establishing a communist party and Cuban as a communist state, and the number of Cuban immigrants to the US swelled. Most Cubans immigrated and stayed in Miami, Florida. The "wet foot, dry foot" policy was set in place in 1995, and stemmed the flow of Cuban immigrants.
National Migration Flows
After the American Civil War, millions of African Americans migrated north to work in the industrial Northeast and Midwest. This continued during the 1920s, declined during the depression (1930s), and resumed its climb.
In the 1970s, the trend started to reverse. African American heading down South again. Although the 1960s civil rights movement didn't change the south overnight, it played a role in the reverse migration. Disillusionment with deteriorating living conditions in the Rustbelt, along with growing economic opportunities drew African Americans southward.
People of Russia migrated east, from the heartland of the Russian state to the shores of the Pacific. This migration altered the cultural mosaic of Eurasia. During the tsarist (1800s-1910s) and communist periods (1920s-1980s), Russia and Soviet rulers tried to occupy and consolidate the countries far eastern frontier. As Russia and then the Soviet Union expanded outward and to the east, the country incorporated ethnic minorities into the country.
During the communist period, the Soviet Union employed the policy of Russification, which sought to assimilate all he people in the Soviet territory into the Russian culture.
1 million Mexicans successfully cross into the US each year. As a result, northern areas of Mexico are experiencing a labor shortage. As a result, Mexican worker from areas farther south in the country are migrating northward. Many of these Mexicans are Huichol Indians, one of Mexico's indigenous populations.
Guest Workers
After WW2, Europe had lost millions of young men in the conflict, so needed laborers to help rebuild their economies.
Workers from poorer European countries migrated to economically growing areas, and millions of foreign workers immigrated from North Africa (majority to France), Turkey (mostly to Germany), the Caribbean, India and Africa. (Many to the UK)
The German Government finally allowed the Turks to become German citizens in 2005.
Guest workers often work as agricultural laborers, or in service industries, including hotels, restaurants, and tourist attractions. Many guest workers are abused by their employer because they don't know their rights.
In Europe, guest workers have created new temples, mosques, restaurants, grocery stores, shops, service industries and changes Europe's cultural landscape.
Refugees
The United Nations High Commissioner on Refugees (UNHCR) estimated that there were 10.55 million refugees in 2010.
The UNHCR organizes and funds international relief efforts and negotiates with governments and regimes on behalf of the refugees.
A refugee is a person who has a wellfounded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, member-ship of a particular social group or political opinion. Countries interpret this in different ways because of how broad "wellfounded" is.
An **IDP or internationally displaced person is a person who has been displaced within their own country. UNHCR estimated that there were 27 million IDPs.
Asylum is the right to protection in the first country in which the refugee arrives.
In Jordan, Palestinian refugees have been so integrated into the host countries national life that they are regarded as permanent refugees. In Lebanon, Palestinians wait in refugee camps for resettlement and still qualify as temporary refugees,
Once violence subsides in a place and the conditions improve, the UNHCR helps return refugees to their homelands, a process called repatriation.
Regions of Dislocation
The region of North Africa and Southwest Asia generates over half of all refugees. Subsaharan Africa comes in second with 20% of the refugees.
In the 1990s, hostility broke out between the Hutu and Tutsi ethnic groups in Rwanda that led to a genocide killing hundreds of thousands and more than 1 million refugees fleeing.
When the US and it's allies started bombing Afghanistan after 9/11, thousands of Afghan refugees climbed across mountains to reach Pakistan and traveled by foot, bicycle, wagon, or open boat.
North Africa and Southwest Asia
Conflict in Afghanistan has lasted more than 30 years, generating the largest refugee flow in the world.
The Gulf War of 1991 and the current war in Iraq have generated millions of refugees. After Iraq invaded Kuwait, many Kurdish people went across the Turkish and Iranian borders. The US made a secure zone for the Kurd's in northern Iraq.
The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan generated a double migration stream into Iran and Pakistan. US support for the Muslim forces helped produce a stalemate, but after Soviet left, a power struggle among Afghan factions generated more migration.
Africa
In 1997, civil wars in Liberia and Sierra Leone sent hundreds of thousands of refugees streaming into Guinea and the Ivory Coast.
The conflict in Sudan was between the north (Arab and Muslim) and the south (black African, christian, or animist). The government in Khartoum, in Muslim north, waged a genocide towards ethnic groups in the south. (1983-2005) 2.2 million died, and 5 million were displaced.
In 2002, north and south made a peace deal, but shortly after violence began in the Darfur region in western Sudan. The Arab-Muslim government began a genocide against non-Arab Muslims in Dafur. The Sudan government funds the Janjaweed, which is the militia behind the genocide.
Genocide is acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole, or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group.
In 2005, northern and southern Sudan signed the Comprehensive peace agreement, which called for a vote of the south's people to decide whether or not to break off as a country. In 2011, south Sudan broke off and officially became a country.
South Asia
South Asia is the third-ranking in refugee numbers because of Pakistan's role in accommodating Afghanistan's refugees
In Sri Lanka, a civil war arose from demands by the minority Tamils for an independent state on the Sinhalese controlled island. It severely damaged the economy and internally displaced 200,000.
Southeast Asia
Between 1 and 2 million people fled Vietnam after the war ended in 1975.
In the early 1990s, Cambodia produced 300,000 refugees escaping their countries violence and ending up in Thailand.
Today, the largest refugee camps are for IDPs in Myanmar. Victims of the 2004 tsunami, 2008 cyclone, and the repressive rule of generals seek refuge in the camps.
Europe
In the 1990s, the collapse of Yugoslavia created the largest refugee crisis in Europe since the end of WW2. Even after the implementation of a peace agreement, the Dayton Records, the UNHCR still reports over 100,000 IDP's in the area.
Other Regions
In the Western Hemisphere, only Columbia has a serious IDP problem, caused by the countries instability associated with narcotics. Some rural areas are beyond the governments control and get attacked by "narcoterrorists."
How do Governments Affect Migration?
The Great Wall, the Berlin Wall, the fences around the Rio Grande and the US were all created to stop immigration.
Legal Restrictions
Legal restrictions are used more often to limit immigration. The US congress designed immigration laws to prevent the immigration of the Chinese to CA.
Waves of Immigration in the US
In the 1800s, US opened its doors to immigration. Most of the immigrants came from Europe
After WW1, the US turned to isolationism and congress feared growing migration. In 1910, the greatest proportion of immigrants came from northern and western Europe.
In 1921, Congress set immigration quotas, whereby each year, European countries could permit the emigration to the US of 3% of it's number of living nationals in 1910. This limited the immigration of southern and eastern Europe
In 1940, congress modified the restrictions on immigration; gave China equal status to European countries, and in 1952, granted Japan similarly and immigration began to rise again.
The US allows 170,000 immigrants per year from countries not in the Western Hemisphere and 120,000 from the Americas. Refugee and guest worker policies have allowed many more immigrants
Many countries practice selective immigration, in which individuals with certain backrounds are barred from entering.
Post-September 11
The government marked 33 countries as countries where terrorist groups operate, and the government automatically detains anyone from these countries entering the US looking for asylum, under "Operation Liberty Shield."
The Justice Department has a policy that allows it to detain any illegal immigrant. The government has stepped up questioning and inspections at travel checkpoints